Uses Modus ponens $$\left( {A,\,\,A \to B\,|\,\, = B} \right)$$ or resolution to show that the following set is inconsistent:

(1) $$Q\left( x \right) \to P\left( x \right)V \sim R\left( a \right)$$
(2) $$R\left( a \right) \vee \sim Q\left( a \right)$$
(3) $$Q\left( a \right)$$
(4) $$ \sim P\left( y \right)$$
where $$x$$ and $$y$$ are universally quantifies variables, $$a$$ is a constant and $$P, Q, R$$ are monadic predicates.